Western Derby Showdown: Can the Eagles Defy Massive Odds at Optus Stadium?


TBC • Optus Stadium • Partly cloudy, no rain forecast
Picture this: West Coast are paying $12 to win. That’s not a typo – the Eagles are literally twelve-to-one outsiders in their own city. When was the last time you saw odds like that in a Western Derby?
I’ve been tracking AFL markets for years, and this is about as lopsided as it gets for a local rivalry.
Both teams come off contrasting results last weekend. Fremantle edged past Collingwood by a single point in one of those nail-biters that had punters reaching for the heart medication.
Meanwhile, West Coast copped a 49-point belting from Richmond at home – their fifth straight loss by an average of 39.4 points. The Dockers have won four of their last five, while the Eagles haven’t tasted victory since Round 14. No wonder the bookies have priced this one accordingly.
KRUZEY’S TIPS
After crunching these numbers, three bets jumped off the page at me.
The margin’s hefty, but there’s still value to be found if you know where to look.
I’m particularly interested in the total points market here – both teams’ recent scoring patterns tell an interesting story that the bookies might have missed.
All odds from Unibet, correct at time of posting
KRUZEY MODEL VS MARKET
Look, I’ll be honest – our data model loves Fremantle here, but maybe not quite as much as the bookies do. We’ve run the numbers through multiple scenarios, and there’s a slight edge that caught my attention.
Our Data Says: Fremantle 91, West Coast 64 (based on season averages adjusted for recent form)
That gives Fremantle a 65.9% win chance, West Coast 34.1%
Bookmakers have Fremantle at $1.03 (97% implied) vs West Coast at $12.00 (8.3% implied)
The Market Edge: West Coast on the line offers surprising value – our 34% chance vs market’s implied 52.6% chance on the +50.5 spread
FORM LINE
I’ve been tracking both teams’ recent form closely, and the contrast couldn’t be starker. Fremantle have won four of their last five matches, with their only loss coming against ladder-leaders Sydney by 11 points.
They’re averaging 84.8 points in this stretch while conceding just 73.6 – solid numbers that suggest a team hitting its straps at the right time of the season.
West Coast’s recent form makes for grim reading. Five straight losses by margins of 49, 26, 59, 29, and 34 points tell you everything.
They’re averaging just 56 points per game in this horror stretch while shipping 95.4 points. That’s a -39.4 point differential that has my alarm bells ringing for anyone considering the Eagles at any price.
- Won 4 of their last 5, averaging 84.8 points for and conceding 73.6.
- Five straight losses by 49, 26, 59, 29 and 34 points; averaging 56 points for, conceding 95.4.
KEY STATS
The season averages paint a clear picture of the gulf between these sides.
Fremantle are averaging 12.2 goals per game compared to West Coast’s 9.2 – that three-goal difference alone explains much of the betting line. But dig deeper and it gets more interesting.
The Dockers dominate the contest with 37.6 clearances per game to the Eagles’ 31.1, while also holding significant advantages in inside 50s (52.3 to 47.6) and contested possessions (131.5 to 119.4). Most tellingly, Fremantle’s disposal efficiency sits at 73.4% compared to West Coast’s 70.8%.
In partly cloudy conditions – with no rain forecast – efficiency will still be a key factor.
12.2
9.2
37.6
31.1
52.3
47.6
131.5
119.4
73.4%
70.8%
THE FINAL WORD
Everything points to a comfortable Fremantle victory, but in derbies, strange things happen.
The 50.5-point line feels about right given recent form, though our model suggests it might be a touch high.
My best bet remains Fremantle to cover – they’ve been too good lately and West Coast too poor to see this staying close. But if you’re after value, that under 162.5 total points looks tasty given West Coast’s scoring woes and the recent pattern of lower-scoring games.
Sometimes the obvious bet is the right one, and this shapes as one of those times.
LOCK IT IN: Fremantle -50.5 @ $1.90
Fremantle to cover the huge spread remains the standout play.
Related:
AFL Draw
Check the AFL Draw for upcoming AFL matches this season.
AFL Injury List
Keep up-to-date with your team’s injuries this week with our AFL injury list.
Other Betting Tips
We don’t just do AFL tips; our experts also specialise in NRL betting tips and horse racing tips.
AFL Grand Final Betting Tips
AFL Tips & Predictions – Grand Final The 2025 Toyota […]
AFL Betting Tips Finals Week 3
AFL Tips & Predictions – Preliminary Finals The 2025 Toyota […]
AFL Betting Tips Finals Week 2
AFL Tips & Predictions – Semi Finals The 2025 Toyota […]
AFL Betting Tips Finals Week 1
AFL Tips & Predictions – Finals Week 1 The 2025 […]
AFL Betting Tips Round 24
AFL Tips & Predictions – Round 24 The 2025 Toyota […]
AFL Betting Tips Round 23
AFL Tips & Predictions – Round 23 The 2025 Toyota […]
AFL Betting Tips Round 22
AFL Tips & Predictions – Round 22 The 2025 Toyota […]
AFL Betting Tips Round 21
AFL Tips & Predictions – Round 21 The 2025 Toyota […]
AFL Betting Tips Round 20
AFL Tips & Predictions – Round 20 The 2025 Toyota […]
AFL Betting Tips Round 19
AFL Tips & Predictions – Round 19 The 2025 Toyota […]
AFL Betting Tips Round 18
AFL Tips & Predictions – Round 18 The 2025 Toyota […]
AFL Betting Tips Round 17
AFL Tips & Predictions – Round 17 The 2025 Toyota […]












