Looking at the Line: St Kilda v Hawthorn Offers Clear Betting Value


Saturday • Marvel Stadium • Roof Closed
Looking at this Round 17 clash at Marvel Stadium, I’ve been tracking these two sides heading in completely opposite directions – and the bookies have noticed too.
After crunching the numbers on recent form and season stats, there’s a clear value opportunity here that most punters might overlook.
St Kilda comes limping into this one with just one win from their last five matches, copping a loss to Gold Coast before that 28-point victory over Melbourne.Their most recent effort – a 12-point loss to Fremantle where they managed just 9.15 (69) – highlighted their ongoing scoring struggles. Meanwhile, Hawthorn’s riding a three-game winning streak, including that demolition of North Melbourne last week where they piled on 23.12 (150).
The Hawks are averaging 92.7 points over their last three games compared to the Saints’ miserable 71-point average over their last five.
KRUZEY’S TIPS
I’ve been waiting for the market to catch up to Hawthorn’s red-hot form, but at $1.34 they’re still offering value considering how completely these teams are trending.
The line’s particularly caught my eye – getting the Hawks at -18.5 when they’re winning by an average of 36.7 points recently feels like a gift.
For those wanting to play it safer, the totals market looks vulnerable given St Kilda’s scoring woes.
All odds from Unibet, correct at time of posting
KRUZEY MODEL VS MARKET
After running the numbers through our prediction model, I’m seeing the Hawks winning but by a margin just under what Unibet are pricing in.
The data’s pointing to a comfortable Hawthorn win, and there’s a notable edge in the head-to-head market that smart punters should exploit.
Our Data Says: St Kilda 75, Hawthorn 92 (based on season averages adjusted for recent form)
That gives Hawthorn a 55.1% win chance, St Kilda 44.9%
Bookmakers have Hawthorn at $1.34 (74.6% implied) vs St Kilda at $3.15 (31.7% implied)
The Market Edge: While the line market’s fairly priced with our 17-point margin prediction sitting just under the -18.5 line, the head-to-head market offers significant value with a 19.5 percentage point gap between our model and the market’s implied probability
FORM LINE
Looking at the recent results, it’s hard to ignore the massive gulf in class between these sides right now. St Kilda’s last five reads like a horror story – losses to Fremantle (12 points), Collingwood (34 points), and a shocking 72-point belting from West Coast.
Their lone bright spot was beating Melbourne, but even that feels like ancient history now.
Hawthorn’s recent run tells a completely different tale. Three straight wins including margins of 85 points (North Melbourne), 3 points (Adelaide in a grind), and 22 points (West Coast) show a team that can both blow opponents away and win the close ones.
The Hawks are scoring at will – their 150-point effort against North was no fluke given their recent offensive explosion.
- L vs Fremantle – 12 points
- L vs Collingwood – 34 points
- L vs West Coast – 72 points
- W vs Melbourne – 28 points
- L vs Gold Coast – margin unknown
- W vs North Melbourne – 85 points
- W vs Adelaide – 3 points
- W vs West Coast – 22 points
KEY STATS
The statistical gap between these teams right now is stark, and it directly influences my betting approach.
In their last five games, St Kilda’s averaging just 71 points while conceding 93 – that’s a differential of -22 points per game. Compare that to Hawthorn’s recent numbers: scoring 78.8 points while conceding just 73.6, giving them a +5.2 differential.
Looking at scoring patterns, St Kilda’s attack has completely dried up.
They’ve kicked more behinds than goals in two of their last three matches, managing just 8.12 and 9.15 in losses. Meanwhile, Hawthorn’s forward line is humming – they kicked 23 goals against North Melbourne and 13 against West Coast.
When you combine St Kilda’s scoring struggles with Hawthorn’s defensive form, the under starts looking very attractive.
78.8
71
93
73.6
3
1
THE FINAL WORD
Everything points to a comfortable Hawthorn victory here. St Kilda’s scoring woes combined with Hawthorn’s defensive strength suggests a low-scoring affair where the Hawks control from start to finish.
The 18.5-point line looks generous given the form differential, making it my best bet for the match.
Don’t overthink this one – back the team in form to cover the line and enjoy what should be a stress-free Saturday night punt.
Related:
AFL Draw
Check the AFL Draw for upcoming AFL matches this season.
AFL Injury List
Keep up-to-date with your team’s injuries this week with our AFL injury list.
Other Betting Tips
We don’t just do AFL tips; our experts also specialise in NRL betting and horse racing tips.
AFL Betting Tips Round 18
AFL Tips & Predictions – Round 18 The 2025 Toyota […]
AFL Betting Tips Round 17
AFL Tips & Predictions – Round 17 The 2025 Toyota […]
AFL Betting Tips Round 16
AFL Tips & Predictions – Round 16 The 2025 Toyota […]
AFL Betting Tips Round 15
AFL Tips & Predictions – Round 15 The 2025 Toyota […]
AFL Betting Tips Round 14
AFL Tips & Predictions – Round 14 The 2025 Toyota […]
AFL Betting Tips Round 13
AFL Tips & Predictions – Round 13 The 2025 Toyota […]
AFL Betting Predictions & Tips Round 12
AFL Tips & Predictions – Round 12 The 2025 Toyota […]
AFL Betting Predictions & Tips Round 11
AFL Tips & Predictions – Round 11 The 2025 Toyota […]
AFL Betting Predictions & Tips Round 10
AFL Tips & Predictions – Round 10 The 2025 Toyota […]
AFL Betting Predictions & Tips Round 9
AFL Tips & Predictions – Round 9 The 2025 Toyota […]
AFL Betting Predictions & Tips Round 8
AFL Tips & Predictions – Round 8 The 2025 Toyota […]
AFL Betting Tips Round 7
AFL Tips & Predictions – Round 7 The 2025 Toyota […]