Game 5 of Round 8 of the 2026 Toyota AFL Premiership predictions on May 3 sees Collingwood vs Geelong at the MCG on Saturday night. You can catch the game live on Kayo, & Foxtel.
Saturday, May 3, 2026
7:35 pm AEDT @ MCG, Melbourne
Final Score Prediction
Magpies
94 : 87
Cats
Win Percentages
Collingwood53.27%
Geelong46.73%
Collingwood
Geelong
Quick Insight
At the time of writing Unibet had the head to head for the Collingwood Magpies set at $1.61, and $2.33 for the Geelong Cats, This sets the bookmakers implied probability for both teams as follows:
Magpies
59.14%
Cats
40.86%
The Betting Edge
The bookies have Collingwood fairly solid favourites with a 59.14% chance, but our deep dive suggests they’re not quite that far ahead, sitting closer to 53.27%. That creates a sneaky bit of value around Geelong at $2.33 if you’re looking for an underdog worth a punt.
The Magpies should still be favourites, but this one feels much tighter than the market suggests.
Power Rankings Breakdown
Let’s see how the two teams stack up across the board:
Predicted Final Score: Collingwood 94 – 87 Geelong
Average Points For: Collingwood 92.57, Geelong 95.00 (Geelong by 2.43 points)
Average Points Against: Collingwood 66.00, Geelong 79.43 (Collingwood much stronger by 13.43 points)
Win Percentage: Collingwood 85.71%, Geelong 57.14% (Magpies by 28.57%)
Over/Under Tempo: 159.4 (Expect a fast-paced match)
Game Style Prediction: Shootout
What to do?
It’s close, Collingwood sit 2nd on the power rankings while Geelong are right behind in 3rd. And when we look at True Power Scores, it’s almost dead even, Geelong actually edge it slightly (4.40 vs 4.60).
Both sides have played strong opponents, but Collingwood’s wins have come against tougher teams (average opponent win % of 65.18% vs Geelong’s 54.76%), giving them a slight form boost.
Offensively, the Cats have the edge in raw and adjusted points, but the Pies are far more solid in the backline, and that could be the key in a game that’s expected to open right up.
All things considered, Collingwood deserve their favouritism, but if you love a bit of value and enjoy riding an underdog, the Cats at $2.33 are one of the few decent underdogs this week.
In what is expected to be a super close game, take the Cats +8.5 line with Unibet to double back yourself incase Geelong almost cause an upset (or do).
Ben's been analysing footy betting markets for over a decade - breaking down team form, player stats, and where the bookies have got it wrong. He leads KRUZEY's weekly AFL and NRL tips and writes our betting app reviews, testing everything from multi-builders to odds competitiveness.
A lifelong Essendon supporter (yes, he's used to disappointment), Ben combines statistical analysis with genuine footy obsession. He watches more game tape than is probably healthy.
Connect on LinkedInEmail Contact