Melbourne vs Carlton Prediction
Carlton are favourite and I’m not going to argue with…

Essendon sit eighteenth and have been beaten by seventy or more three times in the past month, and I am still taking them and the points on Saturday. The change on their side is Jye Caldwell and Archie Perkins back through the middle, which is enough to stop the game getting away in the first twenty minutes. Geelong win this. They just have not been winning by ten and a half goals.
$1.01
$1.91
$1.87
$2.15
Claim Tips at Unibet - Offer unibet
Odds correct at time of posting
The bet here is not who wins. It is whether Geelong have a ten and a half goal performance in them, and nothing they have done lately says they do.
Geelong have won their last three by twenty five, twenty and twenty seven. That is a side grinding out results, not burying opponents. To get past sixty four and a half they need to more than double their best margin of the past month, and nothing about the way they are playing suggests that is coming.
I am not pretending otherwise. Essendon have been beaten by seventy two, ninety three and ninety inside the past month, and if that version turns up this line is nowhere near enough. But those beltings came from sides that put a hundred and thirty or more on them. Geelong have not passed a hundred and twenty in a month.
Getting Caldwell and Perkins back through the middle matters less for the result and more for the shape of it. A bit more midfield means a side that can hold the football long enough to stop the bleeding, and the bleeding is the only reason this line is where it is. That is all I need from them. I am not asking them to win.
Five and a half points. One goal after the siren and I am gone, so I will not sell you this as a comfortable one. I am wearing it because Geelong’s scoring has not been near the level this line needs for a month, and because they give the football back often enough to let a beaten side kick a couple late. That is how their last three finished in the twenties instead of the fifties.
I’ve got Geelong by about ten goals. That is fifty nine against a line of sixty four and a half, so it is tight, and I am taking Essendon and the points anyway.
I’m taking Essendon and the sixty four and a half. The risk is obvious and I have said it plainly: this Essendon has been beaten by ninety inside the past month, so a blowout is not a theory, and five and a half points is not much of a cushion. But Geelong have not produced a ten goal win in over a month, and I am not paying for one now.
Andrew McGrath 20 or more disposals, $1.59. He’s cleared 20 in three of his last six.
Dyson Sharp 20 or more disposals, $1.97. Three on the trot above the mark now, 23 then 21 then 22 last start, and that is a bloke whose role has grown. Four of his last seven have landed it and $1.97 for that kind of form is the best value on the page.
Nate Caddy two or more goals, $1.68. Only the one last start but he snagged three the week before and has bagged two or more in four of his last seven, so the multi goal days keep turning up. If Essendon are going to score at all on Saturday it goes through him.
Zach Merrett 25 or more disposals, $1.77. 28 last start and there is a 35 and a 32 sitting in this run too, so the huge numbers are never far away. Four of his last seven have cleared 25, and a side getting run over spends the afternoon winning the ball back.
Shaun Mannagh to kick a goal, $1.14. He has hit the scoreboard in each of his last four, including that four goal haul, and a goal in four of his last seven. With Geelong winning this by about ten goals the chances will keep coming, and $1.14 is exactly what a steady anchor should look like.
These prop odds are Sportsbet’s, correct at time of posting. Prices move, so check before you bet and take the best one going. Late team changes can knock out any leg.
| Match | Geelong Cats vs Essendon Bombers |
| Date | Saturday, August 8 |
| Kick-off | 4:35pm AEST |
| Venue | GMHBA Stadium |
| Round | AFL Round 22 |
| Status | Scheduled |
| Our Tip | Multi: Geelong Cats Win, Over 183.5 points & Shaun Mannagh Anytime Goal @ $2.15 |
| Predicted Score | Geelong Cats 125 – Essendon Bombers 66 |
Geelong. I’ve got them by about ten goals at GMHBA Stadium, which wins the game comfortably and still leaves the handicap short.
My headline multi at $2.15 takes the straight win with the total and a player prop, Shaun Mannagh Anytime Goal. The win leg anchors it this week; the line bet on the card still stands as its own play.
The match is at GMHBA Stadium in Geelong, kicking off at 4:35pm AEST on Saturday 8 August 2026.
Because there is nothing in it. Everyone knows Geelong win this. The bet worth having is the margin, and that is where I think the line has overshot.
A wet one suits me. Low scoring games are hard to win by ten and a half goals, so if it comes down in Geelong I am happier holding the points, not less.
Geelong play North Melbourne - at Marvel Stadium on Saturday 15 August in AFL Round 23.
Essendon play Sydney - at the MCG on Sunday 16 August in AFL Round 23.