Melbourne vs Carlton Prediction
Carlton are favourite and I’m not going to argue with…

Melbourne host Hawthorn at the MCG on Saturday afternoon and the model has the Hawks winning by 16. The market wants 18.5. The points are the play.
Claim This Tip at Ladbrokes – Offer ladbrokes
Odds correct at time of posting
Hawthorn are the hotter side. Third on the ladder at 6-2, three wins in their last five with a draw against Collingwood mixed in, and a Win-percentage line that has them tracking as a top-four contender for the back half of the year.
Melbourne sit seventh at 6-3 but the form is harder to read. Three wins in their last five with a Demons mascot listed under its Indigenous name ‘Narrm’ in two of those, all of which were close. The Dees have momentum at 106.7, the Hawks have 104.0. That gap is much narrower than the market thinks.
The model has Hawthorn by 16. The market has it at 18.5. That is a 2.5-point edge to take, but the alignment is the bigger story, both numbers say Hawks but the line is fractionally generous. Add the home-deck dividend, the MCG is Melbourne’s deck, and 18.5 looks like a number to take.
If you prefer the H2H, Hawks at $1.38 is the safer play. If you are chasing value, Melbourne plus 18.5 is where it sits.
Back Melbourne plus 18.5 at $1.90; the model has Hawthorn winning by 16 at the MCG, narrowly inside a market line of 18.5 that gives the Demons two and a half points of edge.
The Hawks are the winners but the line is the play. Take Melbourne plus eighteen and a half at $1.90 and let the home deck close the gap.
LOCK IT IN: Melbourne Demons +18.5 @ $1.90
| Match | Melbourne Demons vs Hawthorn Hawks |
| Date | Saturday, May 16 |
| Venue | MCG |
| Our Tip | Melbourne Demons +18.5 @ $1.90 |
| Predicted Score | Melbourne Demons 97 – Hawthorn Hawks 112 |
Our model tips the Hawthorn Hawks to win by 16 points at the MCG. Hawthorn sit third on the ladder at 6 wins, 2 losses and a draw while Melbourne sit seventh at 6 wins and 3 losses.
Melbourne plus 18.5 at $1.90 is our recommended best bet. The market has Hawthorn winning by 18.5 and our model has the margin at only 16. Both sides have 3 wins from their last 5 games and the MCG is Melbourne’s home deck.
The match is at the Melbourne Cricket Ground, kicking off at 4:15pm on Saturday 16 May 2026.
We tipped Hawthorn Hawks to win – incorrect. Final score: Melbourne Demons 120 – Hawthorn Hawks 81.
| Market | Our bet | Result | Units |
|---|---|---|---|
| Head to Head | Hawthorn Hawks H2H @ $1.38 | Loss | -1.00u |
Predicted: Melbourne Demons 97 – Hawthorn Hawks 112. Off by 54 pts on the margin. Season-to-date accuracy and ROI: AFL results page - Afl tips afl results.